Four prominent leaders of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in Karnataka, including two Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs), have filed a petition in the Karnataka High Court seeking the intervention of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in the investigation of the high-profile Rs 94.73 crore scam linked to the Valmiki Scheduled Tribes (ST) Development Corporation. The petitioners in this case include BJP MLAs Basangouda Patil Yatnal and Ramesh Jarkiholi, along with senior party leaders Arvind Limbavalli and Kumar Bangarappa. The BJP leaders are urging the court to direct the CBI to take over the probe into the embezzlement of funds from the ST Development Corporation, as they believe the investigation has not progressed as expected under the current circumstances.
On Friday, the Karnataka High Court took significant steps in the case by issuing notices to the CBI and asking the agency to file a status report on its investigation into the involvement of officials from the Union Bank of India in the financial misappropriation. The court’s move was seen as a step towards greater accountability in the case, which has now become a matter of public concern, involving both political and financial implications.
The BJP leaders, in their petition, have specifically requested that the court direct the CBI to investigate a First Information Report (FIR) registered on June 3, 2024, by the agency in connection with the scam. The leaders are seeking a detailed status report from the CBI about the ongoing probe, focusing on the role of the bank officials from Union Bank of India, whose actions allegedly facilitated the diversion of substantial amounts of money from the ST Corporation’s accounts.
The issue came to light earlier this year when a portion of Rs 187 crore, deposited in the corporation’s account at Union Bank’s MG Road branch in Bengaluru, went missing. This raised alarm bells within the state government and the police, prompting a probe into the matter. The high court’s decision to issue notices to the CBI came after the BJP leaders filed their petition, demanding a more transparent and robust investigation into the alleged wrongdoing.
The situation took a further turn when, earlier in November 2024, the High Court dismissed a plea filed by the Union Bank of India requesting that the investigation into the fraudulent diversion of funds be handed over to the CBI. The bank had argued that, under Section 35A of the Banking Regulation Act, any fraud involving more than Rs 50 crore should be investigated by central agencies such as the CBI. However, the High Court rejected the bank’s application on November 13, stating that such an interpretation of Section 35A would set an unsustainable precedent. The court emphasized that while independent agencies should investigate cases involving ministers or high-ranking officials to ensure credibility and public confidence, this should not automatically imply that all banking-related frauds should fall under the purview of the CBI.
The court’s decision to dismiss the Union Bank’s request was based on the observation that the investigation into this case should be conducted by an independent body, one not under the direct influence of the state government. However, the court also clarified that the broader interpretation of Section 35A, which mandates that all major banking frauds be handed over to central investigating agencies, would not be allowed to extend to all such cases in the future. The judge observed that, while independent investigations are crucial in cases involving high-ranking officials, the CBI should not be tasked with investigating every single banking-related fraud involving state-level institutions.
After his release on bail, former president of Valmiki corporation Nagendra alleged that ED officials coerced him into implicating Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and his deputy, D. K. Shivakumar, in the case. The ED has accused Nagendra of diverting funds from the ST Corporation to finance election-related activities, particularly in the Bellary Lok Sabha constituency during the 2024 elections. Nagendra has denied these allegations, asserting that he was forced to name political leaders to secure his release from custody. His statements have added a new layer of complexity to the investigation, making it a matter of political contention in Karnataka.
The financial scam, believed to have involved the siphoning off of Rs 94.73 crore from the Karnataka Valmiki ST Development Corporation’s account with Union Bank of India, has raised serious concerns about the safety and transparency of government funds. The Karnataka state government originally deposited the money into the bank’s MG Road branch in Bengaluru in March 2024, but a significant portion was transferred to 18 accounts linked to a company in Telangana. These funds were then funnelled into secondary accounts, where they were withdrawn and allegedly used for various illicit purposes, including political campaigns.
A thorough investigation by the Karnataka Police revealed that the funds had been routed through a complex network of accounts in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, reaching over 170 secondary accounts. These accounts were allegedly created by individuals linked to a suspect named Satyanarayana Verma, who has also been accused of similar fraudulent activities in Chhattisgarh in 2022. The scam came to public attention when an accounts officer at the Valmiki ST Development Corporation, who was reportedly involved in the case, tragically took his own life. This incident added a personal and emotional dimension to the ongoing investigation, compelling authorities to take urgent action.
In response to the unfolding crisis, more than 20 individuals have been linked to the fraud, including six Union Bank of India officials, two Valmiki ST Corporation employees, and eight private individuals with alleged ties to Nagendra. The police investigation has already led to the arrest of 14 people, including key figures within the banking sector and the ST Development Corporation. However, the Special Investigation Team (SIT) did not include Nagendra or the Union Bank officials in its initial chargesheet, which has led to further calls for a more thorough and transparent investigation.
The Valmiki ST Development Corporation scam was first uncovered on May 26, 2024, when the mysterious death of an accounts officer, allegedly linked to the missing funds, triggered an investigation. The officer’s tragic death was believed to be connected to the disappearance of a significant portion of Rs 187 crore, which the Karnataka government had deposited into the corporation’s account. Following the discovery of the missing funds, the state government took swift action, prompting the resignation of Nagendra, the minister for tribal welfare, due to the scandal.
Further investigations revealed that the funds were systematically transferred to primary accounts in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, which Satyanarayana Verma and his associates had set up. The funds were routed through more than 170 secondary accounts before being withdrawn. The SIT has arrested several individuals, including Union Bank officials and employees of the tribal welfare corporation, as well as private individuals linked to Nagendra.
The case continues to unfold, with the CBI and the state police under pressure to uncover the full extent of the fraud. The outcome of the investigation will have far-reaching consequences for Karnataka’s political and financial landscape as the public waits for answers regarding the misappropriation of significant public funds intended for the welfare of the state’s tribal communities.
