In a sombre acknowledgement of Ireland’s troubled past, preliminary work has commenced at the site of the former Bon Secours Mother and Baby Home in Tuam, County Galway, where the remains of 796 infants are believed to be interred in a decommissioned septic tank.
The Catholic-run institution, which operated from 1925 to 1961, was a place of systemic neglect and coercion, where unmarried pregnant women were interned, subjected to unpaid labour, and separated from their newborns, many of whom died under appalling conditions.
The excavation, set to begin in full on July 14, 2025, aims to identify and provide dignified reburials for the infants, whose deaths were long obscured by a society steeped in stigma and secrecy.
A grim discovery at Bon Secours
The Bon Secours Mother and Baby Home, locally known as “The Home,” was one of several Catholic-run institutions in Ireland that housed unwed mothers and their children during much of the 20th century. Pregnant women, shunned by a deeply conservative, Catholic-influenced society, were sent to such facilities to give birth in secrecy.
At Bon Secours, they were interned for a year, forced to perform unpaid labour post-delivery, and separated from their infants. The children, often without family consent, were fostered by nuns until adoption, frequently under questionable circumstances.
Official records show that between 1925 and 1961, 796 infants died at the Tuam home, with no burial records to account for their fates.
Local historian Catherine Corless, whose relentless research brought this tragedy to light, discovered that many of these infants were likely disposed of in an old sewage tank, referred to as “the pit,” with only two recorded burials in a nearby cemetery.
“I’m feeling very relieved. It’s been a long, long journey. Not knowing what’s going to happen, if it’s just going to fall apart or if it’s really going to happen,” Corless told Sky News, reflecting on her decade-long effort to uncover the truth.
Her findings, first published in the Irish Mail in May 2014, revealed causes of death including prematurity, convulsions, whooping cough, tuberculosis, meningitis, and diphtheria, with malnutrition cited in a smaller number of cases.
In 2016, a test excavation ordered by the Irish government confirmed “significant quantities of human remains” in underground chambers at the Tuam site, validating Corless’s claims. Forensic analysis later identified the remains as belonging to infants and toddlers, ranging from 35 weeks gestation to three years old, many of whom succumbed to malnourishment, illness, or neglect.
Mother and Baby Homes and Magdalene Laundries
The Bon Secours home was part of a broader network of mother and baby homes and Magdalene laundries, operated by Catholic religious orders with state complicity. These institutions, which functioned as adoption agencies and orphanages, were marked by destitution, misogyny, and high infant mortality rates.
An official investigation into 18 such facilities, concluded in 2021, revealed an “appalling level of infant mortality,” estimating that approximately 9,000 children died across these institutions. The Tuam home alone accounted for 796 of these deaths.
Mothers who gave birth to additional children out of wedlock, labeled as having “reoffended,” were often transferred to Magdalene laundries, infamous institutions for so-called “fallen women,” including sex workers, rape and incest victims, and abandoned or abused female orphans. These laundries, which operated until the 1990s, subjected women to harsh labour and social ostracism.
“We had a completely warped attitude to sexuality and intimacy, and young mothers and their sons and daughters were forced to pay a terrible price for that dysfunction,” said Taoiseach Michael Martin in 2021, during a state apology following the commission’s report. He noted that the children were “buried in a disrespectful and unacceptable way.”
The Sisters of Bon Secours, who operated the Tuam home, issued a “profound apology” and contributed to a compensation plan established in 2022, which has disbursed $32.7 million to 814 survivors.
However, the scale of the tragedy continues to haunt Ireland, with former Taoiseach Enda Kenny describing the Tuam revelations in 2017 as “a chamber of horrors.”
Addressing parliament, he reflected, “No nuns broke into our homes to kidnap our children. We gave them up to what we convinced ourselves was the nuns’ care. We gave them up maybe to spare them the savagery of gossip, the wink and the elbow language of delight in which the holier-than-thous were particularly fluent. We gave them up because of our perverse, in fact, morbid relationship with what is called respectability.”
The Excavation
The excavation at Tuam, overseen by the Office of the Director of Authorised Intervention (ODAIT) under the Irish Institutional Burials Act 2022, is led by forensic investigator Daniel MacSweeney. The operation, expected to take up to two years, aims to recover, analyse, and identify the remains through DNA testing, ensuring a dignified reburial for each child.
The site, now surrounded by a modern housing subdivision, is secured with hoarding and round-the-clock surveillance. Only authorised personnel will access the full property, including a memorial garden, though survivors and families will have opportunities to visit the perimeter in the coming weeks.
“It’s an incredibly complex challenge because of the size of the site and the fact that we are dealing with infant remains that we know, at least in the case of the memorial gardens, are co-mingled,” MacSweeney explained. He noted that the site, originally a workhouse, may also contain remains from the Great Famine of the 19th century, adding to the complexity of the excavation.
“The final timetable will depend on many variables, some of which may only become fully clear as the work progresses,” he added.
Catherine Corless
Catherine Corless’s journey to uncover the truth about Tuam was fraught with challenges. Initially dismissed as “obsessive and delusional” by some, she faced harassment and scepticism from the Catholic Church, politicians, and even international media outlets like Reuters and The Guardian, which questioned her findings and labelled her an “amateur historian.”
Yet, her meticulous examination of death certificates and church records, coupled with her persistence, led to the 2017 test excavation that confirmed the presence of infant remains in the septic tank.
Her work sparked global awareness, prompting the establishment of an Irish commission to investigate mother and baby homes. The commission’s findings, coupled with Corless’s advocacy, culminated in the government’s formal apology and the ongoing efforts to address the legacy of these institutions.
“Irish society has been characterised as being darkly stained by the existence of mother and baby institutions,” Corless stated, emphasising the need for accountability and remembrance.
A Nation’s Reckoning
The Tuam excavation represents a critical step in Ireland’s reckoning with its past, as the country grapples with the systemic abuses enabled by a collusion of church and state. The revelations have exposed a society that, in the mid-20th century, was dominated by rigid Catholic values, stigmatising unwed mothers and their children. The high infant mortality rates, coupled with the disposal of remains in a septic tank, underscore the neglect and dehumanisation endured by those in these institutions.
As the excavation progresses, survivors and families hope for closure and justice. The ODAIT’s mission to “recover and forensically analyse, and to memorialise and bury with respect and dignity, human remains recovered from the site” offers a glimmer of hope for healing.
However, the process also serves as a stark reminder of the need to confront historical wrongs and ensure that such atrocities are never repeated.
Comments