Bookmark Partition revisited as an academic exercise
July 10, 2025
  • Read Ecopy
  • Circulation
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Organiser
  • ‌
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • North America
    • South America
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • Editorial
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Op Sindoor
  • More
    • Analysis
    • Sports
    • Defence
    • RSS in News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Culture
    • Special Report
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • G20
    • Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav
    • Vocal4Local
    • Web Stories
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Law
    • Health
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
MAGAZINE
  • ‌
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • North America
    • South America
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • Editorial
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Op Sindoor
  • More
    • Analysis
    • Sports
    • Defence
    • RSS in News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Culture
    • Special Report
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • G20
    • Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav
    • Vocal4Local
    • Web Stories
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Law
    • Health
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
Organiser
  • Home
  • Bharat
  • World
  • Operation Sindoor
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Culture
  • Defence
  • International Edition
  • RSS in News
  • Magazine
  • Read Ecopy
Home General

Bookmark Partition revisited as an academic exercise

by Archive Manager
Jun 20, 2010, 12:00 am IST
in General
FacebookTwitterWhatsAppTelegramEmail

THE Partition of India in 1947 is an emotive issue for the Indians. While practicality has forced us to accept the reality, the emotional part has probably not come to terms with it. While the political leadership and a section of the interested (vested) media is trying to drum up aman between the two nations, Indians largely look at Pakistan with suspicion, because every talk of normal relations has resulted in military escalation and aggression at the borders at the initiative of Pakistan. That country for ever is trying to outlive the ‘broken away land’ image. Hence any study on the Partition of India can only be an academic exercise, leading to no conclusion.

The recent book The Partition of India by Ian Talbot and Gurharpal Singh explores the events just before 1947 and thereafter in a clinical academic approach, largely skirting the political vortex. According to the authors, the British were reluctant to partition India. This suggestion is a little hard to accept as British had attempted to divide Bengal (1905) and had assiduously followed a policy of divide and rule, alternately shifting the carrot between the Hindus and Muslims, but always viewing them as separate entities. This is no place to recount the measures. The colonial rulers, the book says, were forced to accept Partition to avoid civil war. If this was the case, then they hopelessly misread the situation, failed on intelligence gathering and were unprepared to face the consequences of their action. Partition claimed thousands of lives. Reports vary from two lakh to two million. What a colossal number of human lives!

Talbot and Gurharpal seek to “differentiate” between the communal violence that happened around 1947 to the other incidents of riots before between Muslims and Hindus. They have listed five features: the 1947 violence contained “a desire to squeeze out, or in modern parlance, to ethnically cleanse the minority populations.” Second, violence was not “about religious differences as in the ‘traditional’ riot, but occurred within the end of political context of the contest for power and territory.” Third, the Partition violence was more intense and sadistic; Four, it moved from the previous public arena to private sphere, engulfing women and children; and five, violence evinced great degree of planning and organisation with the support of para-military groups.

The book repeatedly clubs Punjab, Kashmir and the North-East for references on post Independence India’s failures, putting them almost on par with Sind of Pakistan. There is hardly any common threat between them. The Punjab issue only needed a strong arm dealing. In Kashmir it is the combine of Pak-Islam whereas in the north-east the missionaries and the church are stoking the fire. It is also pertinent to point out that all the three regions have received the highest politico-economic support from the Centre. Punjab was the epicentre of Green Revolution, Kashmir has been accorded a special status and the north-eastern states have received sustained attention.

Neither the reasons for 1947 not the consequences of it can be explained by anybody. Paul R Brass has probably best summed up Partition in his book The Production of Hindu-Muslim violence. He said for most Hindus, it was a “Historical scar that not only divided the subcontinent but defied the truth they had fought for as their rightful heritage: the unity of India. Muslims, for their part, fought for another truth invented out of their past in India, namely, that they constituted a separate civilisation distinct from that of the Hindus, that they had always been separate, and would have to remain so in the future.” It is a tragedy that a large number of Muslims who opted to live in secular India continue to nurture this mindset, which has resulted in continued riots post 1947.

Talbot is Professor of History at the University of Southampton and Gurharpal is Nadir Dinshaw Professor of Inter-Religious Relations in the Department of Theology and Religion at the University of Birmingham. The authors have concluded that Partition continues to influence the actions of both the countries though “current developments between them are beginning to look beyond the trap of history that Partition has cornstructed.” The volume is intended for students as an introduction, a base point for the study of modern politics of South Asia. With lots of maps, references and a substantial bibliography, the book is of good academic value.

(Cambridge University Press, Cambridge House, 4281/4, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi 110 002)

ShareTweetSendShareSend
✮ Subscribe Organiser YouTube Channel. ✮
✮ Join Organiser's WhatsApp channel for Nationalist views beyond the news. ✮
Previous News

An enchanting volume of Sangam poetry

Next News

BJP National Executive Meet in Patna Huge turnout at the rally enthuse party; a resolve to rebuild

Related News

Tamil Nadu: Madras HC questions closure of 121 complaints over Ponmudi’s abusive remarks on Hindus; case continues

Tamil Nadu: Madras HC questions closure of 121 complaints over Ponmudi’s abusive remarks on Hindus; case continues

Coke cuts 12 minutes from life: Shocking study reveals deadly impact of ultra-processed foods

Amid MNS-led attacks in Maharashtra, UP responds with flowers: Hindi speakers welcome Marathi families

Housing Minister B.Z. Zameer Ahmed Khan

Karnataka: Congress govt under fire as PMAY-G housing scheme stalls amid fund negligence

Congress leader Jagdish Tytler

1984 Anti-Sikh Riots: Witness tells court Tytler softly threatened him by claiming killing of hundreds of Sikhs

Key accused in Coimbatore Blasts Case Tailor Raja arrested

Coimbatore 1998 Blasts: Key accused and Al-Umma Operative Tailor Raja arrested after 26 years

Load More

Comments

The comments posted here/below/in the given space are not on behalf of Organiser. The person posting the comment will be in sole ownership of its responsibility. According to the central government's IT rules, obscene or offensive statement made against a person, religion, community or nation is a punishable offense, and legal action would be taken against people who indulge in such activities.

Latest News

Tamil Nadu: Madras HC questions closure of 121 complaints over Ponmudi’s abusive remarks on Hindus; case continues

Tamil Nadu: Madras HC questions closure of 121 complaints over Ponmudi’s abusive remarks on Hindus; case continues

Coke cuts 12 minutes from life: Shocking study reveals deadly impact of ultra-processed foods

Amid MNS-led attacks in Maharashtra, UP responds with flowers: Hindi speakers welcome Marathi families

Housing Minister B.Z. Zameer Ahmed Khan

Karnataka: Congress govt under fire as PMAY-G housing scheme stalls amid fund negligence

Congress leader Jagdish Tytler

1984 Anti-Sikh Riots: Witness tells court Tytler softly threatened him by claiming killing of hundreds of Sikhs

Key accused in Coimbatore Blasts Case Tailor Raja arrested

Coimbatore 1998 Blasts: Key accused and Al-Umma Operative Tailor Raja arrested after 26 years

Accused Gurudeep Singh arrested by Bengaluru Police

Karnataka: 26-year-old held in Bengaluru for recording women without consent and sharing clips on social media

J&K Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha

J&K: LG Manoj Sinha says two-phase ropeway to Shri Amarnath being considered for helping elderly, divyangjan

US President Donald Trump

Donald “Tariff” escalates global trade tensions with harsh import taxes, hits Brazil & developing nations in crackdown

“Our border is with Tibet, not China”: Arunachal CM Pema Khandu strikes at heart of Beijing lies

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Cookie Policy
  • Refund and Cancellation
  • Delivery and Shipping

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies

  • Home
  • Search Organiser
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • South America
    • Europe
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • Editorial
  • Operation Sindoor
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Defence
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Business
  • RSS in News
  • Entertainment
  • More ..
    • Sci & Tech
    • Vocal4Local
    • Special Report
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Law
    • Economy
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
  • Subscribe Magazine
  • Read Ecopy
  • Advertise
  • Circulation
  • Careers
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Policies & Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Refund and Cancellation
    • Terms of Use

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies