The Muslim appeasement in Bengal is so strong that even die-hard supporters of Hindu cause from Rajasthan and Northeast who have been staying in Kolkata have now turned into proponents of Mamata Banerjee’s Khela Hobe school of thought
The Muslim voters helped Trinamool win 2021 elections
Politics or the outcome of the electoral process do not shape up in a day. History and contemporary sociology are key factors too. Thus, analysing a verdict would require taking a closer look at multiple aspects.
Unlike Punjab, there would be Bengali’ refugees from East Pakistan who had landed in Calcutta in 1947- 48 and died after four-five decades still without a house of their own. This was hardly the case with people crossing over to Delhi and parts of north India from West Pakistan. Fast pace to circa 2020.
West Bengal minister for Mass Education and Library Services, Siddiqullah Chowdhury, wasted no time and said that ten persons who were arrested by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) from West Bengal and Kerala for their alleged link to a terror module of Al-Qaeda were “innocent.”
Still raising the issue of ‘minority appeasement was wrong or even sinful – so think ‘Sickular’ intellectuals and Bhadralok in Kolkata. So much appealing and convincing is Kolkata’s influence on people’s mindset vis-a-vis Muslim appeasement that few years of stay in ‘City of Joy’ have often converted die-hard supporters of Hindu cause from Rajasthan or northeast turn into strong proponents of Mamata Banerjee’s ‘Khelahobe’ school of thought.
In the 2021 elections, the ISF of Abbas Sidiqqui slogged hard in South 24-Parganas and North 24- Parganas, telling Muslims how the Mamata had kept them merely as a vote bank. Yet, the voters went with TMC. There are 64 seats from these two districts – North 24-Parganas with 26 per cent Muslim population has 33, and South 24-Parganas with 35.5 per cent Muslims accounts for 31 assembly seats. Of these seats, only five came to the BJP.
In Murshidabad district, Mamata-Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury (only formidable Congress leader) old rivalry came to the fore. Trinamool Congress gave a shocker to the Congress, picking up as many as 18 from the region. Incidentally, 66.27 per cent of the population here are Muslims.
The Bhadralok might have let down the BJP poll managers. But for the saffron party, the battle was always pretty tough in the state. For all practical purposes and historical legacies, the chemistry of Bengal politics always put the BJP on the back foot. The same was the case with the Bharatiya Jana Sangh and Hindu Mahasabha too.
The Bhadralok might have let down the BJP poll managers. But for the saffron party, the battle was always pretty tough in the state. For all practical purposes and historical legacies, the chemistry of Bengal politics always put the BJP on the back foot. The same was the case with the Bharatiya Jana Sangh and Hindu Mahasabha too
Hence a jubilant TMC leader told this journalist: “Didn’t we tell, the BJP arithmetic was poor on the chemistry of Bengal politics”. As many as 70 seats minimum were already with Mamata. So, Trinamool’s 213 win in the ultimate is ‘win’ of 143. Hence the overconfidence – “Khelahobe”. Please recollect, during campaigning too, Mamata Banerjee herself said, the BJP would at best manage around 70 seats.
The BJP leaders in Bengal knew about this. Hence there was reluctance on the part of many prominent leaders to contest elections. Still, banking on the Narendra Modi factor did help many BJP candidates sail home.
In Malda, despite 51 per cent Muslims, out of 12, the BJP managed a win in four and eight seats went to TMC. Even from Hindu voters’ trust with BJP perspective, demography was an important decider in this year’s polls; but the absence of Hindu unity was visible.
It can be argued that the Leftists campaign made Hindus almost forget the real reason for being rendered homeless in East Pakistan and even ethnic cleansing. They developed a craze to run for jobs. In Coach Behar, with 74.1 per cent Hindus, BJP won 7 out of 9. In Alipurdwar, BJP had a clean sweep.
In Jalpaiguri, despite 84.16 per cent Hindus, out of 7, three seats went to TMC and 4 to BJP.
In Darjeeling district, the BJP scored a neat five, and the 74 per cent Hindu population knew whom to vote for. In North Dinajpur, seven seats, seven went to Mamata camp and the remaining 2 for BJP. Here Hindu-Muslim population was 49.31 to 49 per cent. South Dinajpur voters gave each TMC and BJP three seats each. Here Hindu population is around 73.55 per cent.
The Hindu voters’ strength did not help BJP in Kolkata, Howrah and Hooghly.In Howrah, despite a 73 per cent Hindu population, all 16 seats went to TMC mainly because of Muslim consolidation.
In Paschim Medinipur, the Mamata-led outfit managed 13 seats out of 15, although 86.52 per cent of voters were Hindus. However, in Purba Medinipur, out of 16 seats, BJP’s share was seven as against 9 of Trinamool Congress.
Similarly, Kolkata’s 11 seats went to TMC despite a 76.6 per cent Hindu population. In Hooghly, BJP managed to win four out of 18 as 82.89 per cent Hindu population stood divided. But around 15 per cent of Muslims came together as a bloc.
