Conservative Estimates Ostrich like comrades in Nandigram
Monday, July 4, 2022
  • Circulation
  • Advertise
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Organiser
  • ‌
  • Bharat
  • World
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Defence
  • Sports
  • Business
  • More
    • RSS in News
    • Special Report
    • Culture
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Obituary
SUBSCRIBE
No Result
View All Result
Organiser
  • ‌
  • Bharat
  • World
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Defence
  • Sports
  • Business
  • More
    • RSS in News
    • Special Report
    • Culture
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Obituary
No Result
View All Result
Organiser
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bharat
  • World
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Culture
  • Defence
  • RSS in News
  • Subscribe
Home General

Conservative Estimates Ostrich like comrades in Nandigram

Archive Manager by WEB DESK
May 20, 2007, 12:00 am IST
in General
Jeay Sindh Freedom Movement chairman Sohail Abro

Jeay Sindh Freedom Movement chairman Sohail Abro

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterTelegramEmail

The Communist Party of India (Marxist) has to date blame everybody and everything-from the Naxalites to the CIA-for Nandigram. Given its intolerant and self-righteous disposition, it cannot brook any dissent, even if it is expressed by the fellow-traveling intellectuals. So, unsurprisingly, when a group of 50 intellectuals visited Nandigram recently, the CPM cadre attacked them.

What, however, may appear surprising is the almost total silence of the intellectual class over not only this particular attack but the entire Nandigram episode-the CPM goons murdering innocent villagers. Of course, there were a few rumblings, like some Marxist academics returning awards they were given by the Left Front Government of West Bengal, but on the whole their response was muted. One has to know the mindset of intellectuals to understand their unfussy reaction on Nandigram.

I would like to add that overlooking the depredations of communism by intellectuals is not a purely Indian trait; great authors, journalists, and thinkers have done it in the West as well. Lenin coined an interesting term, ?useful idiots,? for the intellectuals who unquestioningly accepted Marxian lies. They are useful, because their praise for Marxism bestows legitimacy and a verisimilitude of veracity on the ideology; and they are idiots, because they are able to see its rotten core.

Download Organiser App

There is the example of Walter Duranty. A star reporter with New York Times who went on to win Pulitzer, he reported from the Soviet Union when the murderous regimes of Lenin and Stalin were killing people in millions. Duranty, however, wrote rosy accounts from the Soviet Union when collectivisation and purges eliminated millions. Even when 25,000 Ukrainian peasants were dying every day, Duranty refused to expose the barbarity of communism. Having accepted the ends-justify-the-means argument, he even condoned communist butchery by saying, ?You can'tmake an omelet without breaking a few eggs.? On this a commentator, Mark Y Herring, remarked, ?Those ?eggs? were the heads of men, women and children and those ?few? were tens of millions.?

But Duranty was not alone. In his Modern Times, the historian Paul Johnson wrote about reaction of Western intellectuals to Stalinist brutalities:

In the outside world, the magnitude of the Stalin tyranny-or indeed its very existence-was scarcely grasped at all. Most of those who traveled to Russia were either businessmen, anxious to trade and with no desire to probe or criticise what did not concern them, or intellectuals who came to admire and, still more, to believe. If the decline of Christianity created the modern political zealot-and his crimes-so the evaporation of religious faith among the educated left a vacuum in the minds of Western intellectuals easily filled by secular superstitions. There is not other explanation for the credulity with which scientists, accustomed to evaluating evidence, and writers, whose whole function was to study and criticise society, accepted the crudest Stalinist propaganda at its face value. They needed to believe; they wanted to be duped. [emphasis added]

For such intellectuals, the Soviet Union was their pilgrimage-you don'tgo on pilgrimage with a questioning mind. So, Sidney and Beatrice Webb lauded a project built with slave labor. Harold Laski praised Soviet prisons for enabling convicts to lead ?a full and self-respecting life.? George Bernard Shaw compared British jails, where a human being is transformed into a criminal, with Russian prisons where a man entered ?as a criminal type and would come out an ordinary man but for the difficulty of inducing him to come out at all. As far as I could make out they could stay as long as they liked it.? This about the most horrendous slave camps mankind has ever witnessed!

The mendacity of Leftist intellectuals and liberals was unbounded. According to Johnson:

The famine of 1932, the worst in Russian history, was virtually unreported. At the height of it, the visiting biologist Julian Huxley found ?a level of physique and general health rather above that to be seen in England.? Shaw threw his food supplies out of the train window just before crossing the Russian frontier ?convinced that there were no shortages in Russia??

Estimates of Stalin written in the years 1929-34 make curious reading. HG wells said he had ?never met a man more candid, fair and honest? no one is afraid of him and everybody trusts him.? The Webbs argued that he had less power than an American president and was merely acting on the orders of the Central Committee and the Presidium? He [Stalin] was, said the Chilean writer Pablo Neruda, ?a good-natured man of principle??

?Self-delusion was obviously the biggest single factor in the presentation of an unsuccessful despotism as a Utopia in the making. But there was also conscious deception by men and women who thought of themselves as idealists and who, at the time, honestly believed they were serving a higher human purpose by systematic misrepresentation and lying. If the Great War with its unprecedented violence brutalised the world, the Great Depression corrupted it by appearing to limit the options before humanity and presenting them in garishly contrasting terms. Political activists felt they had to make terrible choices and, having made them, stick to them with desperate resolution. The Thirties was the age of the heroic lie. Saintly mendacity became its more prized virtue. Stalin'stortured Russia was the prime beneficiary of this sanctified falsification. The competition to deceive became more fierce when Stalinism acquired a moral rival in Hitler'sGermany.

The Western intellectual has lived his ?heroic? lies with aplomb, but his Indian counterpart is not far behind; he can give the Western intellectual a run for his money when it comes to ?heroic? lies and ?saintly mendacity.? Even a thrashing by the Red goons is unlikely to wake them up and make them see the reality. And the reality is that communism is the most violent ideology mankind has ever witnessed; it is an ideology that was responsible for the killing of more than 100 million people in the world.

Would our intellectuals ever dare to see the reality of communism? Or would they continue to blindfold themselves so that they could continue to loiter in their dwell dreamscapes?

(The author works with The Political and Business Daily.)

ShareTweetSendShareSend
Previous News

What did Karunanidhi say about cultural significance of Ramar Paalam (Ram Sethu)?

Next News

CPM goondaism; Visva Bharati, Santiniketan Comrades muzzle academician for political vendetta

Related News

‘2G fame’ DMK leader A Raja raises secessionist bogey, threatens to fight for ‘independent Tamil Nadu’ | Watch Video

‘2G fame’ DMK leader A Raja raises secessionist bogey, threatens to fight for ‘independent Tamil Nadu’ | Watch Video

DEFENCE SCAN:  RAKSHA MANTRI REVIEWS SECURITY SITUATION IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

DEFENCE SCAN: RAKSHA MANTRI REVIEWS SECURITY SITUATION IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

Silence of the Lions

Silence of the Lions

Conversion by Church : Jainism Facing  Existential Threat

Conversion by Church : Jainism Facing Existential Threat

Amravati Beheading: Mastermind Shaikh Irfan sent to police custody till July 7

Amravati Beheading: Mastermind Shaikh Irfan sent to police custody till July 7

All problems of northeast will be solved by 2024, Amit Shah tells BJP meet

All problems of northeast will be solved by 2024, Amit Shah tells BJP meet

Comments

The comments posted here/below/in the given space are not on behalf of Organiser. The person posting the comment will be in sole ownership of its responsibility. According to the central government's IT rules, obscene or offensive statement made against a person, religion, community or nation is a punishable offense, and legal action would be taken against people who indulge in such activities.

Latest News

‘2G fame’ DMK leader A Raja raises secessionist bogey, threatens to fight for ‘independent Tamil Nadu’ | Watch Video

‘2G fame’ DMK leader A Raja raises secessionist bogey, threatens to fight for ‘independent Tamil Nadu’ | Watch Video

DEFENCE SCAN:  RAKSHA MANTRI REVIEWS SECURITY SITUATION IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

DEFENCE SCAN: RAKSHA MANTRI REVIEWS SECURITY SITUATION IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

Silence of the Lions

Silence of the Lions

Conversion by Church : Jainism Facing  Existential Threat

Conversion by Church : Jainism Facing Existential Threat

Amravati Beheading: Mastermind Shaikh Irfan sent to police custody till July 7

Amravati Beheading: Mastermind Shaikh Irfan sent to police custody till July 7

All problems of northeast will be solved by 2024, Amit Shah tells BJP meet

All problems of northeast will be solved by 2024, Amit Shah tells BJP meet

Maharashtra: Eknath Shinde, Devendra Fadnavis sworn in as Chief Minister, Deputy CM at Raj Bhawan

PM Modi, Shah’s decision to make me CM opened eyes of many: Eknath Shinde in Maharashtra Assembly

PM Modi’s directive to recruit 10 lakh people in 1.5 years will bring new hope and confidence among youth: Amit Shah

Amit Shah slams Opposition for negative politics, targeting Modi in 2002 Gujarat riots case

All Above 18 Eligible for Vaccination From May 1, Announces Centre

India’s COVID vaccination coverage exceeds 197.95 cr

BJP’s Rahul Narwekar elected as Maharashtra Assembly Speaker

BJP’s Rahul Narwekar elected as Maharashtra Assembly Speaker

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Cookie Policy
  • Refund and Cancellation
  • Delivery and Shipping Policy

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bharat
  • World
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • Defence
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Business
  • RSS in News
  • Special Report
  • Sci & Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Education
  • Books
  • Interviews
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Obituary
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Circulation
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Refund and Cancellation

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies