In the United States, some Islamic organisations have come under criticism for defending individuals accused of serious crimes solely based on their Muslim identity. For example, the Al-Ihsan Islamic Centre in Minnesota issued a community support letter in July this year for Qalinle Ibrahim Dirie, a Somali Muslim immigrant convicted of raping a 12-year-old girl. Dirie received a 12-year prison sentence.
Born in Somalia during the country’s civil war, Dirie spent much of his early life in a Kenyan refugee camp before migrating to the US in 2006. Although his citizenship status is unclear, he has primarily lived in Minnesota and North Dakota.
This incident took place in July 2024. A Somali Muslim immigrant, Dirie, was accused of raping a 12-year-old girl in Minneapolis. The victim was playing in her backyard when Dirie approached her from an alley. He allegedly asked if her mother was home, and the girl said no. He left but soon returned, forcing her into a car, where he drove a short distance and assaulted her. The victim was eventually able to escape and return home.
Following the incident, Dirie was arrested. In May of the following year, a court found him guilty of first-degree criminal sexual conduct. After his conviction, Dirie’s family sent letters to the judge, asking him to consider Dirie’s character and alleged community contributions when determining his sentence.
ST. PAUL, MN: An Islamic Center in Minnesota recently wrote a “community support letter” on behalf of 41-year-old Qalinle Ibrahim Dirie, a Somali immigrant who abducted and raped a 12-year-old girl.
The letter, written to ask the judge to consider a lighter sentence for Dirie,… pic.twitter.com/9nBqLwcRK3
— FRONTLINES TPUSA (@FrontlinesTPUSA) August 2, 2025
In addition to the family’s letter, the Al-Ihsan Islamic Centre also submitted a “Community Support Letter for Qalinle Dirie” to the judge. “We, the undersigned members of the Somali community, write this letter to convey our sincere and strong support for Qalinle Dirie, a respected member of our community,” the letter states.
In an attempt to justify Dirie’s heinous crime, the Islamic Centre claimed that “Dirie faced the challenge of starting over in a new culture” and described him as an outgoing, family-oriented person prior to “this situation.”
The letter emphasised Dirie’s love for his family and children and highlighted his active involvement as a volunteer at the Al-Ihsan Islamic Centre mosque, “where he regularly attended Friday prayers, Ramadan, and community events.”
“You would often find him helping elders find rides home or staying after to help clean up. His service was never about recognition — just a quiet commitment to supporting the spaces that hold our community together. The situation [Dirie] is currently facing comes as a deep shock to all of us. It does not reflect the man we know, a man whose actions have consistently reflected family and community. We respectfully ask that this letter be considered as a sincere reflection of who Qalinle Dirie truly is. His contributions may not make headlines, but to us, he has made a positive difference,” the letter, signed by Ahmed Anshur, executive director of the Al-Ihsan Islamic Centre, reads.
By portraying a convicted rapist as a hero and victim solely because of his Muslim identity, the Al-Ihsan Centre completely ignored the gravity of his crime and failed to condemn his actions.
