As India celebrates 75 years of its Constitution coming into effect this January 26, it is an opportune moment to reflect on its ideals, efficacy, and brilliance. This anniversary calls upon every conscientious Indian to strengthen the foundational principles of the Constitution and ensure its enduring relevance.
Seventy-five years ago, India was primarily recognised through its rich heritage, culture, traditions, and historical records. However, the creation of a constitutional India began alongside the framing of the Constitution. This sacred mission aimed to establish a legal framework for a newly independent nation, requiring the drafting of a comprehensive document outlining the laws that would guide its governance. Members of the Constituent Assembly faced the colossal task of balancing India’s ancient cultural heritage with the progressive ideals of modern governance.
Certain members, including K V Kamath, Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, Govind Das, Ghanashyam Gupta, Kalluru Subbarao and Ram Sahay, emphasised that the Constitution should align with India’s historical ethos and cultural values. They frequently cited texts like the Vedas, Puranas, Ramayana and Mahabharata to underline their vision. In contrast, some members, including representatives of the Muslim League and sections of the Congress, leaned towards preserving colonial structures or disregarding India’s cultural roots. This divergence of ideologies is evident in the recorded debates of the Constituent Assembly.
Dr B R Ambedkar stood as a towering figure against efforts to dilute India’s identity or subjugate it to external influences. Addressing concerns in the Assembly, he firmly stated, “This Constituent Assembly, even before it commenced its work, rejected all directives from the British Parliament. None of the members here, including myself, would accept or allow British directives to become part of this Constitution.” His resolute stance shielded the Constitution from being infiltrated by colonial remnants or ideologies that sought to undermine India’s cultural and political sovereignty.
Despite Ambedkar’s firm leadership, there were attempts to steer India towards a communist framework. A glaring example was the amendment proposed on September 18, 1949, by Asaf Ali and supported by Ashraf Mohani, who had previously been associated with the Congress and later joined the Muslim League. The amendment sought to declare India a “Union of Socialist Republics,” reminiscent of the Soviet model. Mohani questioned why Ambedkar had structured India as a “Union of States” rather than a “Federation of Republics.” He argued that India should embrace socialism and called for changes to align with this vision.
Ambedkar’s response was categorical. He rejected the proposed amendment, emphasizing that it was against the nation’s foundational ethos. He argued that the Constitution’s directive principles already incorporated the essence of socialism without succumbing to extremism. He cautioned that binding future generations to rigid ideologies like socialism through constitutional mandates would stifle progress and freedom of thought.
The debates also revealed significant pressure from members like Mohani, Naziruddin Ahmad, Imam Hussain, and T. T. Krishnamachari, who advocated for radical socialism and secularism to be enshrined in the Constitution. Despite their persistence, Ambedkar held firm, declaring, “I will not allow ideas that are alien to our native culture and traditions, such as extreme socialism, to infiltrate this Constitution.”
A notable example of Ambedkar’s commitment to safeguarding India’s unity was his staunch opposition to Article 370, which granted special status to Jammu & Kashmir. Despite vehement opposition, the provision was included, creating decades of disparity and division in the nation. Ambedkar foresaw the challenges such provisions would bring and resisted them to the best of his ability.
The Constituent Assembly debates make it evident that India’s transformation into a communist state was averted due to Ambedkar’s unwavering resolve and vision. Had he not chaired the Drafting Committee with such determination, India might have drifted towards a political model that disregarded its cultural heritage and diversity. His efforts ensured that the Constitution remained a document rooted in the nation’s traditions while embracing progressive ideals.
As we celebrate 75 years of the Indian Constitution, it is imperative to acknowledge and honour the legacy of Dr B R Ambedkar. His love for the nation, coupled with his commitment to justice and equality, serves as an inspiration for every Indian. The youth of India must imbibe his patriotism and dedication, ensuring that the nation remains true to its roots while progressing towards a brighter future.
Comments