Patna High Court upholds Nitish Kumar Govt’s caste-based survey
September 28, 2023
  • Circulation
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Organiser
  • ‌
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • North America
    • South America
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • G20
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • International
  • More
    • Sports
    • Defence
    • RSS in News
    • Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav
    • Politics
    • Vocal4Local
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Special Report
    • Culture
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Law
    • Health
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
MAGAZINE
No Result
View All Result
  • ‌
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • North America
    • South America
    • Africa
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • G20
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
  • International
  • More
    • Sports
    • Defence
    • RSS in News
    • Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav
    • Politics
    • Vocal4Local
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Special Report
    • Culture
    • Sci & Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Law
    • Health
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
Organiser
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bharat
  • World
  • G20
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Culture
  • Defence
  • International Edition
  • RSS in News
  • Magazine
Home Bharat Bihar

Patna High Court upholds Nitish Kumar Govt’s caste-based survey

The Bihar Government had argued that its caste-based survey was on the verge of completion and the stay on it is causing an irreparable cost to the state. Notably, the estimated cost of the survey stands at about Rs 500 crores

by WEB DESK
Aug 1, 2023, 02:45 pm IST
in Bihar
Bihar Caste Census

Patna High Court upholds Bihar Government's Caste Based Survey

FacebookTwitterWhatsAppTelegramEmail

On August 1, the Patna High Court upheld the caste-based survey being conducted in Bihar. The court’s Division Bench, comprising Chief Justice K Vinod Chandran and Justice Partha Sarthy, dismissed the petitions challenging the Bihar Government’s caste-based survey.

Earlier, on July 21, the Supreme Court dismissed the Bihar Government’s appeal against the Patna High Court’s May 4 order issuing an interim stay on the caste-based survey, in view of the high court reserving a verdict in the case on July 7. The court said that the Bihar Government’s plea challenging the stay had become infructuous.

The Nitish Kumar Government had moved the Supreme Court challenging the Patna High Court’s May 4 order, contending that the survey was on the verge of completion and the stay on it is causing an irreparable cost to the state. It is pertinent to note that the estimated cost of the survey stands at about Rs 500 crores.

Related News: Bihar Caste Census: Nitish Govt moves Supreme Court against Patna High Court’s May 4 order granting an interim stay

“The State has already completed more than 80% of the Survey work in some districts less than 10% of work is pending. The entire machinery is at ground level. There shall be no harm in completing the exercise subject to final adjudication of the dispute. The time gap to complete the survey would adversely affect the survey since this would not be contemporaneous data…the stay of collection of data itself would cause a huge loss to the State since, if finally the action of the State is upheld, the State would be required to put logistic in place with additional expenditure and burden on public exchequer,” the Bihar Government’s plea before the Supreme Court read.

Furthermore, the Bihar Government has also challenged the Patna High Court’s finding that the conduction of a ‘caste-based survey’ amounts to a ‘census’, and thus the state does not have the power to conduct it. The government contends that the power of the state to conduct a survey is traceable to various entries of List III, Part-3 and Part-4 of the Constitution of India.

It is also averred that the collection of caste-based data is a constitutional mandate under Articles 15 & 16 of the Constitution of India. Furthermore, the Government of India and the State Governments have enacted the National and State Commission of Backward Classes Act, and that its effective implementation requires quantifiable data. “The provisions of the Act can be effectively implemented only when the State has data based on caste,” the Bihar Government’s plea read.

Background
On May 4, the Patna High Court stayed the caste-based survey being conducted in Bihar with immediate effect. The Patna High Court reserved its judgement on a petition challenging and seeking an interim stay on the enumeration of castes and economic survey in Bihar on May 3.

The petitioner’s counsel argued that the ‘caste survey’ is a census in form and content and pointed out that the authority to carry out a census is with the Government of India under Entry 69 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India. Furthermore, the counsel argued that the State Government cannot carry out a caste census as it has no legislative competence and, in that circumstance, neither can an executive order be sustained under Article 162 of the Constitution of India.

Furthermore, it was argued that when a survey is carried out, it has a specific objective which is absent in the caste survey which raises the question of whether the present survey carried on as a caste-based one. It was also argued that the survey is, in effect, a census aimed at eliciting the caste status of the individuals native to the State.

Related News: Big Blow to Nitish Kumar Govt: Patna HC stays caste-based census in Bihar; says power to conduct census with Union Govt

The petitioners also raised a contention that such a census would be violative of an individual’s privacy. The petitioner’s counsel placed emphasis on two points; one, the expenditure of Rs.500 Crores and the dissemination of information to all the political parties, as is proclaimed in the notification itself.

The State Government’s counsel, Advocate General argued that there is no law prohibiting disclosure of caste. The Advocate General contended that “on the question of privacy, it is to be mentioned that there is no law prohibiting the disclosure of caste nor the exercise of a survey carried out by the State of Bihar. In the Indian context, it cannot be said that disclosure of caste is a violation of privacy; especially when the same is disclosed for the purpose of reservation and availing benefit of welfare schemes by the citizens themselves, voluntarily.”

The Patna High Court noted, “It is the vehement contention of the State that the entire data now collected is available in the public domain; different individuals having given it for the purpose of availing reservation, social welfare measures, getting employment and so on and so forth. If the details are available in the public domain, we fail to understand why such a massive exercise, expending public resources has to be undertaken.”

“We are convinced that the survey, in the manner in which it is carried out, cannot be said to be within the policy realm of the State. Even the defence raised was to source the State’s power to legislate under the Concurrent List; which we have found to be untenable,” the Patna High Court had said, while staying the Bihar Government’s caste-based survey on May 4.

The Patna High Court had held that prima facie the caste-based ‘survey’ amounts to a census which only the Government of India has the power to carry out. The court stated, “On the above reasoning, we find that the caste-based survey is a census in the garb of a survey; the power to carry out which is exclusively on the Union Parliament which has also enacted a Census Act, 1948.”

The Patna High Court noted, “Though it has been vehemently urged that both Houses of the State Legislature has sanctioned the survey, there is nothing placed on record regarding the deliberations made or the objects sought to be achieved by embarking upon such a massive exercise, that too for the collection of details which include the sensitive issue of caste.” The court added, “There are broad reasons stated in the counter affidavit, but nothing comes out from the notification, nor is any specific reasoning or object stated to have motivated the initiation of the exercise of a caste-based survey, which reasoning or motivation should also be relatable to a time, contemporaneous with the time of bringing out the notification.”

“We are of the considered opinion that the petitioners have made out a prima facie case against the continuation of the process of caste-based survey, as attempted by the State of Bihar. There is also the question raised of data integrity and security which has to be more elaborately addressed by the State,” the court said.

“Prima facie, we are of the opinion that the State has no power to carry out a caste-based survey, in the manner in which it is fashioned now, which would amount to a census, thus impinging upon the legislative power of the Union Parliament. We also see from the notification issued that the Government intends to share data with the leaders of different parties of the State Assembly, the ruling party and opposition party which is also a matter of great concern. There definitely arises the larger question of right to privacy, which the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held to be a facet of right to life,” the court held.

The Patna High Court concluded, “In such circumstances, we direct the State Government to immediately stop the caste-based survey and ensure that the data already collected are secured and not shared with anybody till final orders are passed in the writ petition.”

Topics: Bihar Caste Based CensusNitish Kumartejashwi yadavPatna High CourtBihar governmentBihar Caste CensusBihar Caste Survey
ShareTweetSendShareSend
Previous News

Lebanon clashes: 11 killed, several injured in Palestinian refugee camp

Next News

“Will donate prize money to Namami Gange project”: PM Modi after receiving Lokmanya Tilak National Award

Related News

Caste-Based Census: SC to hear plea challenging caste survey in Bihar on August 18

Caste-Based Census: SC to hear plea challenging caste survey in Bihar on August 18

Patna High Court

‘Not able to bear child due to disease not ground for divorce, husband’s marital duty to cooperate’: Patna High Court

BJP leader Nityanand Rai lashes at Bihar CM Nitish Kumar over lawlessness and police firing on protesters in Katihar

BJP leader Nityanand Rai lashes at Bihar CM Nitish Kumar over lawlessness and police firing on protesters in Katihar

Bihar: Law and order continues to deteriorate in Nitish Kumar Govt; BJP worker stabbed to death by miscreants in Purnia

Bihar: Law and order continues to deteriorate in Nitish Kumar Govt; BJP worker stabbed to death by miscreants in Purnia

Jungle Raj Returns in Bihar: Back to back murders jolt the State; 6 killed in a day in separate incidents

Jungle Raj Returns in Bihar: Back to back murders jolt the State; 6 killed in a day in separate incidents

Bihar Caste-Based Census

Bihar Caste-Based Census: Supreme Court disposes of Nitish Govt’s plea against stay as Patna HC reserves its verdict

Load More

Comments

The comments posted here/below/in the given space are not on behalf of Organiser. The person posting the comment will be in sole ownership of its responsibility. According to the central government's IT rules, obscene or offensive statement made against a person, religion, community or nation is a punishable offense, and legal action would be taken against people who indulge in such activities.

Latest News

Being Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh: A symbol of relentless struggle and courage

Being Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh: A symbol of relentless struggle and courage

Remembering Lata Mangeshkar on her Birth Anniversary, tracing her journey in Film industry

Remembering Lata Mangeshkar on her Birth Anniversary, tracing her journey in Film industry

Bhagat Singh Birth Anniversary: A revolutionary and a great martyr

Bhagat Singh Birth Anniversary: A revolutionary and a great martyr

“About 75,000 people can have easy darshan…160 pillars on ground floor”: Nripendra Misra on Ram Temple in Ayodhya

“About 75,000 people can have easy darshan…160 pillars on ground floor”: Nripendra Misra on Ram Temple in Ayodhya

Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal faces the heat: CBI to probe Rs 45 crore allegedly spent on bungalow renovation

Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal faces the heat: CBI to probe Rs 45 crore allegedly spent on bungalow renovation

Manipur Govt declares entire State ‘Disturbed Area’ under AFSPA for 6 months, except jurisdiction of 19 police stations

Manipur Govt declares entire State ‘Disturbed Area’ under AFSPA for 6 months, except jurisdiction of 19 police stations

India ageing report 2023 unveils insights into elderly care challenges and solutions

India ageing report 2023 unveils insights into elderly care challenges and solutions

Minor Rape

Maharashtra Shocker: Eight-year-old raped by 53-year-old in Mumbai’s Jogeshwari area

Tamil Nadu: High level VHP delegation meet TN Governor and submits a memorandum on Sanatan row

Tamil Nadu: High level VHP delegation meet TN Governor and submits a memorandum on Sanatan row

China-Pakistan Economic Corridor cooperation faces hurdles in energy, infrastructure projects: Report

China-Pakistan Economic Corridor cooperation faces hurdles in energy, infrastructure projects: Report

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Cookie Policy
  • Refund and Cancellation
  • Delivery and Shipping

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bharat
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chhattisgarh
    • Jharkhand
    • Maharashtra
    • View All States
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • South America
    • Europe
    • Australia
    • Global Commons
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Defence
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Business
  • RSS in News
  • Entertainment
  • More ..
    • Sci & Tech
    • Vocal4Local
    • Special Report
    • Education
    • Books
    • Interviews
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Law
    • Economy
    • Obituary
    • Podcast
  • Subscribe Magazine
  • Advertise
  • Circulation
  • Careers
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Policies & Terms
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Refund and Cancellation
    • Terms of Use

© Bharat Prakashan (Delhi) Limited.
Tech-enabled by Ananthapuri Technologies