Left propaganda website Newsclick allegedly received Rs 38 crore from abroad which was channelled through Neville Roy Singham, an American of Sri Lankan origin, who works for the Chinese Communist Party
The point that foreign funding has been used and abused to misuse the power of new generation media tool – the websites – has again made news after the Enforcement Directorate found something questionable about ‘Newsclick’. BJP spokesman Sambit Patra was angry and he ventilated his anguish saying thus: “The only agenda of these so-called portals and Newsclick is to spread the propaganda of a foreign nation and defame India. Some foreign powers and Indian politicians have teamed up to spread unrest”. Newsclick has of course denied any wrong doing.
It has been reported by between 2018 and 2021, ‘Newsclick’ received Rs 38 crore from abroad and the money was allegedly channelled through Neville Roy Singham, an American of Sri Lankan origin, who works for the propaganda arm of the Chinese Communist Party.
Often the entire media propaganda policies are misguided.In the 1980s under Rajiv Gandhi, actually the misuse of Doordarshan and All India Radio had reached its peak. But in the ultimate did it really help Rajiv Gandhi or Congress? In 1989 fiercely contested general elections – Rajiv-led Congress was voted out making way country’s first multi-party Government headed by V P Singh. This was an era in India when noted TV critic Amita Malik had said: “The national news stars Rajiv Gandhi and HKL Bhagat and the local news features only HKL Bhagat and HKL Bhagat, a local Delhi-based leader.”
The then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi’s media management think-tank was quite an empowered team comprising Rajiv-Sonia’s trusted man Mani Shankar Aiyar, G Parthasarathy (both IFS), senior IAS officer T N Seshan, who later transformed him to be a hard nut Babu as Chief Election Commissioner who would ‘discipline’ netas and also R K Dhawan, a principal hand in Delhi’s corridors of power from Indira Gandhi era.
Likes of Information and Broadcasting Minister H K L Bhagat, who was named in 1984 anti-Sikh riots, simply carried out the job sincerely. Congress insiders had even circulated a line that so-called ‘credibility’ of Government and tax-payers money-run DD and AIR was only a ‘urban phenomenon’ and there was no-holds-barred propaganda has been launched “to win over the rural Indian voters”. K KTewary, a member of Rajiv’s shouting brigade during Bofors row, was junior minister of Information and Broadcasting and he had famously said: “Credibility of DD and AIR is only the concern of cocktail circuit in Delhi”.
Ironically the same ‘cocktail circuit’ is today’s Left liberal and biggest class of protectors of democracy.And in 2021 – the ‘Lutyen’s club’ or better known also as ‘Khan Market gang’ – do not mind any campaign directed by foreign media including China; provided the propaganda (read free of expression – sic) is directed well against Narendra Modi and his Government.
This was the era when Rajiv Gandhi was usually found repeating his one-liner in pidgin Hindi “humeydekhnahae….”. In fact, the election campaign was launched with Rajiv’s slip of the tongue: “Hum jeetengeyaloosenge…”.
This was the time when Marxist doyen JyotiBasu had said: “Doordarshan is not Congress Zamindari”. The Leftists were furious – of course not withstanding their new found-bonhomie with the Congress in 2021- because the West Bengal Government’s legitimate request for an ‘advertisement’ for raising funds for the Bakreshwar Thermal Power plant was denied by Doordarshan Kolkata.
Clicking With China
The Enforcement Directorate has found that a part of the money was also paid to Urban Naxal Gautam Navlakha who has been arrested in the Elgar Parishad Case.The ED investigation found that Newsclick’s parent company, PPK Newsclick Studio Pvt Ltd., had received money from Justice and Education Fund Inc, US; GSPAN LLC, US; Tricontinental Ltd Inc, US- all have the same office address. In the records, Newsclick has shown that most of the money it received was for “export of services”. But, Newsclick founder and Editor-in-Chief comradePrabirPurkayastha could not explain what services did Newsclick export.
Newsclick also made payments to Bappaditya Sinha, CPM IT Cell executive.The ED has found a series of mails linking payments to creating a pro-China narrative. Newsclick was expected to justify China’s crackdown on Alibaba founder Jack Ma, justify China’s pro-development work in Africa, etc. PrabirPurkayastha told The Times of India it was possible that Singham had shifted to China as it was safe during the pandemic.Purkayastha could not explain to the Enforcement Directorate why an electrician was paid Rs1.55 crore.
Under N T Rama Rao, TDP faced similar problems in Andhra Pradesh. Later on all opposition parties had ‘boycotted’ DD for a while. Chief Minister NTR’s scheduled radio broadcast speech was once ‘edited’ out in Hyderabad! DMK Chief Minister M Karunanidhi’s speech was declined to be telecast for the reference to India-Sri Lanka agreement. Between 1984 and 1989, the government had invested a whopping Rs 800 crore for DD and AIR expansion programmes involving huge amount for construction of buildings, setting up TV towers, etc.
By mid-1989, India had 20 million TV sets – a four times rise since December 1984. Data claimed nearly 74-75 per cent of India’s population was covered by DD and this was against just about 18 per cent in 1986.On the other hand, it was being argued that as the newspapers were generally turning against Congress – except a few like the one English tabloid in Kolkata – the Government had enhanced the price of newsprint at least 200 percent.
Even the Customs duty for glazed newsprint imported from outside was increased. Around the time there were officials like Shiv Sharma, one of the bosses in DD, who had said: “….even projection of national achievements is perceived as propaganda by opposition parties”. Old timers among TV viewers would recall that so much preference had to be given to Rajiv’s speeches that the infamous students protest in China would get pushed as number 3 in terms of headline. This was an era when a serial depicting AlokNath in specs was cancelled as the actor almost looked like V P Singh. For ‘objective news’, helpless Indians waited for a 40-minute programme every Friday evening’s ‘The World This Week’ run by a well-known ‘bearded’ TV anchor who today has again turned himself into a ‘nothing doing’ face of a so-called sickular media house.
