READERS' FORUM

Published by
Archive Manager

“Kill us instead of deporting to Pakistan” (Organiser, 25.12.2011); It is indeed heart wrenching to read the plight of Pakistani Hindus in Organiser. There were some reports in the media in this regard, but the horrible scenes that have been described in the reports of Organiser are really heartbreaking. You have done a great job by documenting the plight of these unfortunate people, as even we the Hindus of India were not deeply aware of the agony of these people. The Government of India must grant them political asylum without delay and should also make a constitutional provision that the Hindus born in any part of the world can get Indian citizenship at any stage of their life, if they are tortured there.

— Vinod  Gupta, BA/5C, Phase II, Ashok Vihar, Delhi- 110 052

Bhagwad Gita is the heart and soul of the great Indian civilisation (Organiser, 1.1.2012); The move by a Russian court to impose a ban on the Gita on the ground that the sacred book encourages hatred was absured. In Mahabharat, of which the Gita  is a part, Arjun is directed by his guru Lord Krishna  to fight his cousins and others who had cheated the Pandavas of their  kingdom and molested  and humiliated their  wife Draupadi. Lord Krishna did not preach hatred or revenge but exhorted his friend-disciple to reinstate  moral order. Eventually, all is well that ends well. The rejection by a Russian court of a petition seeking a ban on the book, The Bhagavad Gita As It Is, brings the curtain down on what has been an absurd  demand by a bunch of fanatics in Tomsk, a town in Siberia, to ban the book because it promotes ‘extremism’ among Russian’s various communities.

— Mahesh  Chandra  Sharma, E-198, Panki, Kanpur

Banning Gita is equal to slighting Bharat! (Organiser, 1.1.2012); Since its publication Bhagwad Gita has been translated into  60 languages including Russian and is widely considered among the best selling Indian texts in the world. There is nothing wrong in the 18 chapters of Gita and in no way it can be connected to terrorism. It is just the story of Mahabharat. Moreover, a number of western thinkers have immersed themselves in the Gita, its  layers reflecting  the difficulties—and ultimately simplicity—of human life.

— Bibhu Dutt Patel, Orissa

Congress in Lokpal tangle (Organiser, 1.1.2012); The Lokpal issue happened to be a test of sincerity for the parliamentarians in fighting corruption. But the present lot has not only failed in it but also has injected the virus of caste and religion-based reservations even in the proposed Lokpal body. Democracies thrives on politics which unites society and takes a nation forward. Unfortuntely, the case is just the opposite in the largest democracy of the world, where politics is all about divide and rule. The UPA government deliberately brought a Bill with controversial provisions so that it does’nt get clearance and the government could then blame the BJP and other Opposition parties.

— Bharat Arora,  Mayur Vihar 1, Delhi 110 091

Manmohan jettisoning economy to help sinking Euro zone (Organiser, 4.12.2011)  This is with reference to the front page news item ‘Manmohan jettisoning economy to help sinking Euro zone’ and articles, ‘UPA sinking India for saving doomed Euro zone’ and  ‘Clueless UPA demure at World Economic Summit’ on page 2 and 3 of your esteemed weekly. All these articles,  are thought provoking, timely and highly informative. What a layman understands today is that without discussing in  the Parliament or without any  consent form the electorates the UPA Government  is committing treason by trying to save Euro zone  at the cost of India. I have been always saying that the Congress  is the government of the foreign powers and for the foreign powers but unfortunately been managed by Indians who are their  agents. My stand has been proved by your article. Euro zone is an ‘Imperialistic Zone’ and it must go so that other peace loving nations can rise and prosper. Euro Zone prospered all these years at the cost of other developing nations. Now let them turn to bankruptcy and let those who were looted earlier now prosper and loot these looters.  Reforms by the IMF, WB and UNSC will come only when developed countries sink financially. Let West sink so that the desired reforms become a reality.

— Pramod  Prabhakar  ValsaNgKar, Dilsukhnagar, Hyderabad-500 060

UPA government has no guts to take action Nation is quite aware of how Varun Gandhi, youth leader and BJP MP was arrested under National Security Act by the  Mayawati government during his campaign for the last Lok Sabha elections. her government had contended that his address was inflamatory, provocative, creating enemity between the two communities and also dangerous to the national security. What he had said in his speech? He had only said that whosoever oppose Hindutva, their hands should be chopped off. Hue and cry was raised on his statement. Entire pseudo-secularist brigade appreciated Mayawati and welcomed his arrest under NSA. If so what about warning and threat given by the so-called activist of human rights, Prof Syed Abdul Rahaman Geelani of Delhi? He has  warned that if Afzal is send to gallows there will be conflagration in the entire the Kashmir Valley. Inspite of this not a single so-called secularist came forward to condemn his statement nor demanded his arrest under NSA and sedition. See their double standard.

— Sridhar  V  KUlkarni, Tilak Chowk Kalyan (West) 421 301 Maharashtra

Pak schools foster Hindu hatred: US This  is  with reference to news in  Organiser, dated 27.11.2011 under the heading ‘Pak schools foster Hindu hatred: US’. It has been mentioned  in the US government report, that “Social Studies textbooks in Pakistan are rife  with negative comments regarding India and Great Britain, but Hindus are often singled out for particular criticism in texts and in interview responses.” It is worth noting, that this report is by the US government and not by any  Hindu or Indian organisation. On the other had, government of India and most of the Hindu and Indian NGO organisation are busy in appeasement of Pakistan, and hope for good relations, which is nothing more than a mirage. No wonder that  very recently three Hindus brother  doctors have been gunned down, and condemning of these killings by Pakistan Prime Minister Yusaf Raza Gilani as per report in The Tribune dated 10.11.2011, is nothing more than lip sympathy, only to befool Indian leadership. India government must take this issue of teaching hatred against Indian and Hindus with the Pakistan government at the highest level, otherwise such gunning down of Hindus in Pakistan, and terrorism by Pakistani nationals in India would go on increasing. It is not only the maulavis and madrasas that teach hatred against the Hindus and non-Muslims, but it is the official policy of government of Pakistan to teach Hindu hatred  to young boys and girls  in schools as part of their  curriculum. I would suggest, that  BJP should take up this issue in the Parliament and ask Manmohan Singh to speak to the Prime Minister of Pakistan, who has issued a certificated to his Pakistani counterpart as ‘A  man of Peace’.

— Anand  Prakash,  72/Sector-8, Panchkula-134 109

Ataturk and triumph of nationalism over Islam Apropos the letter of  Tanveer Fatima  under the caption given above (Organiser, September 11, 2011). She has objection for reviewing the book Ataturk. An intellectual Biography  at a time when pro-Islam wind is blowing and Mustafa Kamal’s figure as the pioneer of Turkish nationalism is on decline. The very tone of this letter exposes her inherent mind that nationalism is abhorent for her as regards Islam. It means Islam is above nationalism. She also feels happy in her heart that the stigma of the ‘sickman’ of Europe adhered to Turky could not be removed in spite of Turkish nationalism’s revival. As per the wordings of this letter, Islam is supreme and nationalism has no value and power as compared to Islam in her eyes. But here one may like to enquire from her, if nationalism is so meaningless as  compared to Islam, then why there are nearly five dozen ‘Islamic Nations’ ? Why are they fighting ferocious wars amongst themselves such as those of Iraq-Iran wars; Pakistan’s internal war that created Bangladesh and such others. Nationalism prevails over Islam in every Islamic country. Even so called Arab countries are not one single entity in spite of all of them following the same type of Islam. It appears that the very cause of her concern is that Ataturk was a very revolutionary and staunch nationalist hero of Turky, which was till then under the shadow of  ‘Arab Cultural Imperialism’. He was bold and courageous enough to dethrone the ‘Khalifa’ and establish a secular democratic regime under him. Arabs and to those who are their cultural slaves, the name of Kamal Ataturk will always pinch in their  innermost heart. Can Tanveer Fatima say that she is not one of them?

—Anand  Mishra ‘Abhay’,
Sanskriti Bhawan, Rajendra Nagar, Lucknow-226 004

Parliamentarians can set standards Parliament is now no more a civilized place. India is going through  dangerous times as the very symbol of democracy is under scrutiny.  With walkouts and adjournments becoming the norm in  the Parliament, people feel cheated. The quality of debates and discussions in the House has dipped  beyond imagination. The Prime Minister doesn’t  want to engage in any debate with the Opposition.  It’s  true that politicians can’t  expect people to respect an institution till they start respecting it themselves.

—Ritha Sagar, Chennai

Anna still has support of people The Congress and its supporter have been trying  to mislead the country by saying that Anna Hazare is playing politics in the hands of the BJP and targetting the Congress. But the truth is that Anna is fighting for a national cause, i.e. removal of corruption that  covers all the political parties. Despite the various attempts by the Congress to weaken Anna’s  movement  by making baseless allegations against him and his team members, about 55 per cent of Indians continue to support Anna. The nation wants a strong Lokpal Bill and it wants the PM and the CBI to be covered under it.

— Raminder  Singh, B-224, Naraina Industrial Area, Phase-1, Delhi


Sreedharan Pillai’s father passes away

VG Sukumaran Nair, father of distinguished lawyer, writer and former BJP Kerala State President (now Prabhari of Lakshadweep) Adv. Shri PS Sreedharan Pillai, expired.He was 83. His funeral rites were held on 29.12.2011.  The BJP Parliamentary Party Leader Shri LK Advani, BJP Deputy Organising Secretary Shri V Satish, Kerala Chief Minister  Shri Ommen Chandy, Central Ministers Shri Mullappally Ramachandran and Shri KV Thomas, Kerala Assembly Speaker Shri G Karthikeyan consoled the bereaved family. The RSS  All India Sharirik  Pramukh  Shri KC Kannan, Prant Sahpracharak Shri Venu, Prant Sahkaryavah Shri S Easwaran, Kerala Culture Minister Shri KC Joseph, BJP National Leader Shri O Rajagopal and other distinguished personalities from different walks of life attended the funeral and paid their last respects to the departed soul. (FOC)

Share
Leave a Comment